Direct Answer: In a technology M&A transaction, the buyer’s counsel drafts the definitive agreement — the SPA, disclosure schedules, and ancillary documents. That drafting advantage translates directly into economic outcomes: the definitions they choose, the rep survival periods they establish, and the indemnification carve-outs they include or omit have measurable dollar consequences for the seller. Experienced seller’s counsel closes those gaps. Inexperienced seller’s counsel lets them stand. Most founders significantly underestimate how much the quality and experience of their legal team affects their net proceeds — independent of the headline purchase price.
Why the Drafting Party Has a Structural Advantage
In most technology M&A transactions, the buyer provides the first draft of the definitive agreement. This is convention, not law — but it is convention with significant consequences.
The party that drafts controls the starting point. Every negotiation begins from their document, which means every deviation from their preferred terms requires the seller to identify the issue, articulate why it is problematic, and persuade the buyer’s counsel to move. The buyer’s counsel, meanwhile, is defending a document they wrote specifically to protect their client’s interests.
This is not nefarious — it is how M&A transactions work. But founders who treat the legal process as a formality that follows the real negotiation at the LOI stage consistently discover at closing that terms they thought were standard were in fact heavily buyer-favorable, and that their counsel either did not catch them or did not push back effectively.
The SPA is not a formality. It is where the economics of your deal are finalized.
The Four Battlegrounds Where Counsel Quality Matters Most
1. Representation Definitions and Qualifiers
The representations and warranties section of an SPA is where the seller makes legally binding statements about the business. Each rep is a potential indemnification obligation — if the rep is breached, the buyer can make a claim against escrow or, in cases of fraud, against the seller personally.
The scope of each rep is determined by its definition and qualifiers. “Material adverse effect” is one of the most negotiated definitions in any M&A transaction — it determines what triggers a MAC clause, which determines whether the buyer can walk from a deal post-signing. Buyer’s counsel will define it narrowly; seller’s counsel should push for a broader definition that excludes industry-wide downturns, macroeconomic conditions, and changes in law.
Knowledge qualifiers matter equally. A rep made “to the knowledge of the company” is a very different obligation than a rep made without qualification. Experienced seller’s counsel will push for knowledge qualifiers on every rep where actual knowledge is the appropriate standard, and will define “knowledge” carefully — limiting it to the actual knowledge of named individuals rather than constructive knowledge of anything a reasonable investigation would have revealed.
The difference between a qualified and unqualified rep on a $30M deal can be millions of dollars in indemnification exposure.
2. Indemnification Structure and Caps
The indemnification section determines how much you can lose after closing. Buyers want unlimited recourse; sellers want to cap their exposure at the escrow amount. The negotiated outcome typically lands somewhere in between, but the structure matters enormously.
Basket (deductible): Buyers want a tipping basket — once claims exceed the basket threshold, they can recover from dollar one. Sellers want a true deductible — only the amount above the basket is recoverable. On a $25M deal with a $250K basket, the difference between a tipping basket and a true deductible is $250K in the seller’s pocket on any moderately sized claim.
Cap: The standard negotiating position for sellers is that the indemnification cap equals the escrow amount — meaning the buyer’s recourse is limited to what is held in escrow. Buyers often push for a higher cap on specific reps (tax, environmental, IP ownership). Seller’s counsel should resist any cap above the escrow amount except for claims involving actual fraud, which are typically uncapped as a matter of law.
Fundamental rep carve-outs: Buyers will argue that fundamental reps (capitalization, authorization, title) should survive indefinitely and be subject to a higher cap, often the full purchase price. This is partially market — some extended survival on fundamental reps is standard — but experienced seller’s counsel will negotiate meaningful time limits (3–6 years) even on fundamental reps, and will resist full-purchase-price caps.
3. Disclosure Schedule Preparation
The disclosure schedules are the seller’s opportunity to qualify the representations — to list exceptions, carve-outs, and known issues that would otherwise constitute a breach. A thorough disclosure schedule is the seller’s primary defense against post-closing indemnification claims.
Most founders understand this in theory. In practice, disclosure schedule preparation is where inexperienced seller’s counsel consistently underperforms. The instinct is to disclose as little as possible to avoid drawing the buyer’s attention to issues. This is precisely backwards. Thorough disclosure protects the seller; sparse disclosure creates exposure.
The standard in most SPAs is that the seller is liable for any breach of a rep unless the issue was specifically disclosed. If a customer contract has an assignment restriction that was not disclosed and the transaction triggers it, that is a breach — regardless of whether the seller knew about it. Experienced seller’s counsel will conduct a thorough sweep of every representation in the agreement, identify every potential exception, and disclose it.
The disclosure schedule review process is also where seller’s counsel can identify reps that are simply not accurate as written — and push back on the rep itself rather than attempting to schedule around it.
4. Interim Operating Covenants
Between signing and closing, the seller is typically bound by interim operating covenants that restrict how the business can be run. These covenants are negotiated in the SPA and are a common source of post-signing friction.
Standard covenants require the seller to operate in the ordinary course of business, maintain existing customer and supplier relationships, and refrain from taking significant actions (hiring above certain salary thresholds, entering new material contracts, making capital expenditures above specified limits) without buyer consent.
The scope of these restrictions is negotiated. Buyer’s counsel will draft them broadly; seller’s counsel should narrow them to what is genuinely necessary to preserve the business the buyer is paying for, while preserving the seller’s ability to run the company normally in the interim period.
Overly broad interim covenants create two risks for sellers: they constrain normal business operations in ways that can harm the business, and they create technical breach exposure if the seller inadvertently violates a covenant during the pre-closing period.
What Experienced Seller’s Counsel Actually Does
The value of experienced M&A counsel is not primarily in identifying issues — though that matters. It is in knowing which issues are worth fighting for and which concessions to trade away.
An inexperienced seller’s attorney will often fight every point, creating friction without adding value and consuming time and goodwill on minor issues. An experienced M&A attorney knows that buyer’s counsel will always concede on some points in exchange for wins on others — and has a clear view of which battles produce the most economic value for the seller.
The practical consequence: experienced seller’s counsel typically produces better economics on escrow, indemnification caps, and rep qualifiers — the terms that directly affect how much money the seller walks away with at closing and how much exposure they retain post-closing. The additional cost of experienced M&A counsel is consistently smaller than the economic value they produce on these terms.
The right time to engage counsel is before the LOI, not after. Seller’s counsel who is involved in LOI negotiations can push to establish key economic terms — escrow amount, indemnification cap, exclusivity period — before the definitive agreement is drafted. These terms are significantly harder to move once they are documented in a signed LOI.
The Questions to Ask When Selecting Seller’s Counsel
The quality of M&A counsel varies dramatically, and the signals are not always obvious. Firm size is not a reliable proxy — some large firms staff M&A transactions with junior associates; some boutique M&A firms have partner-level attention on every deal.
The right questions: How many technology M&A transactions at comparable deal sizes has this attorney personally led — not supervised, personally led — in the past three years? What is their standard approach to disclosure schedule preparation? Can they provide references from founders who have sold technology companies at a similar stage?
The attorney who handled your Series A has done M&A work. That is not the same as an attorney whose primary practice is technology M&A and who has negotiated these specific provisions dozens of times.
The choice of seller’s counsel is one of the highest-leverage decisions a founder makes in the exit process. It deserves the same diligence as the choice of investment banker.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does it matter that the buyer’s counsel drafts the SPA? Yes, materially. The drafting party controls the starting point for every negotiation. Seller’s counsel’s job is to identify the deviations from market standard and push back effectively — but they are always working from the buyer’s document, which is drafted to protect the buyer’s interests.
What is the most important thing to negotiate in an SPA? The indemnification structure — specifically the cap, the basket type (tipping vs. true deductible), and the survival periods for different categories of reps. These terms directly determine the seller’s post-closing financial exposure.
Should seller’s counsel be involved before the LOI? Yes. Key economic terms including escrow amount, indemnification cap, and exclusivity period are often included in the LOI and are harder to move once documented. Involving counsel before LOI signing allows the seller to push on these terms while they are still being negotiated.
What makes a rep “fundamental” and why does it matter? Fundamental reps cover core characteristics of the company — its legal existence, ownership structure, authorization to enter the transaction, and title to assets. They typically survive longer and are subject to higher indemnification caps than general business reps. Sellers should negotiate defined survival periods even on fundamental reps and resist full-purchase-price liability caps.
How does R&W insurance interact with the SPA negotiation? When R&W insurance is in place, the economic stakes of individual rep and indemnification negotiations shift — the insurer bears the primary risk on covered claims. However, the SPA reps still determine what is covered under the policy, and disclosure schedule preparation remains equally important (insurers will exclude undisclosed known issues from coverage).
Is seller’s counsel typically the same as the company’s existing general counsel? They can be, if the GC has substantial M&A transaction experience at comparable deal sizes. In most cases, founders use outside M&A counsel for the transaction, either instead of or alongside their GC. The transaction is a one-time event with permanent economic consequences; it warrants specialist representation.
Telegraph Hill Advisors works closely with founder’s counsel throughout every transaction we advise on. We have a network of experienced technology M&A attorneys who have represented sellers in lower middle market transactions and understand both the market standards and the leverage points that matter most. If you are preparing for a transaction and want a recommendation, we are happy to make introductions.